Showing posts with label Simon Dwyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Simon Dwyer. Show all posts

Friday, 2 May 2014

National Rehabilitation League (2014)

This week we have seen the great news coming from both the Newcastle Knights in regards to Alex McKinnon.

McKinnon suffered a horrible spinal injury when he fell awkwardly in an illegal spear tackle earlier this year. Initially there were fears he’d be a quadriplegic.

Since then he has shown insurmountable spirit and courage to try and get himself better. He can move his head and he is able to move both arms and hands. He even has some sensation in his legs.

Alex is a fighter and his recovery is remarkably inspiring. He has an entire community of Rugby League fans around the world wishing him the best.

This week the NRL announced that they would create a job for life for Alex if he requires it. The Newcastle Knights, who had been in contract negotiations with him earlier this year, signed him to a contract over 3 years. Intelligently too, the NRL waived this contract from the Knights salary cap.

Magnificent gestures all round by all involved.

Today, an article called Simon Dwyer the NRL’s dirty secret. Simon Dwyer was a very promising second rower for the Wests Tigers who was touted as a future Origin star, and rightfully so.

But an attempted tackle resulted in Dwyer receiving a spinal injury. While Dwyer can still walk and function reasonably well, he has next to no function in his right arm. The tone of the article was to emphasise that both Dwyer and McKinnon received spinal injuries, McKinnon rightfully received a lot of support while Dwyer, it was assumed, had received nothing.

While the assumption is unfair and mostly incorrect, for me it raises another issue, about player welfare. Each club has their own doctors and rehabilitation staff for their contracted players. But what happens when those players suffer career ending injuries? They retire and are barely heard of since.

And in most cases, they are not providing the services of their former clubs medical and rehabilitation services.

Now I’m going to go on a tangent here briefly. Yesterday the Liberal Government released its commission of audit, essentially a briefing outlining where money could be saved. In a number of cases this even suggested some departments could be closed down completely, leaving many highly skilled and qualified people without work.

As I looked through the list I saw one department and instantly thought of Simon.

Commonwealth Rehabilitation Services (or CRS) is a department that specialises in helping disabled (be it physically, mentally, or both) find sustainable work that doesn’t impact on their disability and ensures that they can produce a high standard of work and earn a good income (essentially reducing or removing the need of money they receive from welfare). It was initially set up to help returned servicemen from World War II.

If this department were to close, the NRL could make a very wise and intelligent move, possibly even the most significant and forward thinking concept of any professional sporting body in the world. They could hire a heap of these highly skilled people to work with players who suffered career ending injuries to help them find alternative work and to keep in touch with them to make sure they are coping well.


It would be essentially the game turning full circle and going back to its first reason of coming into existence, the welfare of the players.

Saturday, 10 August 2013

Player Wel(un)fare? (2013)

Last night I attended the top of the table clash between Melbourne and Souths at AAMI Park in Melbourne.

I sat just two rows away from the sideline. In the second half, Dylan Farrell (Souths), Andrew Everingham (Souths) and Sisi Waqa (Melbourne) contested a kick into the Melbourne in-goal.

Farrell stumbled just as the other two went to leap for the ball, as he fell the side of his head collided heavily into team mate Everingham's knee, knocking him out.

What transpired is of greatest concern.

As Farrell lay on the ground in the Storm in-goal, briefly unconcious, play continued. As he started to come to, the Souths trainer treating him, attempted to get Farrell back on his feet. Farrell took 3 or 4 unsteady steps, lost his balance and collapsed to the ground again, still in the Storm-in goal, but within less than a metre of the sideline.

The Souths trainer then signalled for assistance.

He then dragged Farrell's body off the field so that Souths could bring on a replacement, as they were playing with 12 men.

The ensuing few minutes saw the trainer ask for a stretcher. When assistance arrived, Farrell was also put in a neck brace before being stretchered from the field.

Firstly, this incident is not isolated. Round 16, 2011 saw 22 year old Wests Tigers second rower Simon Dwyer suffer a nerve injury in a freak accident on the field. He too was walked off the field with some very mediocre assistance. Since that day, Dwyer has not played any Rugby League, and he still has not fully recovered after requiring a nerve graft.

By no means am I suggesting that trainers should be doctors, but what I am saying is that the game and its on-field player welfare practices is downright abysmal.

Regarding last nights game, why couldn't Souths run on a 13th player immediately after Farrell's injury if play is not going to be stopped? It would not have given Souths an unfair advantage.

If that is too complicated, then why not stop play and get the injured player off the field first?

Either of these options is an immensely superior concept to the current methods in place.

My father-in-law who attended the game has worked as a medic for the Army and for St Johns Ambulance in England during major sporting events. He was mortified at what he saw last night and said, the best policy when treating someone injured like that is to not move them until you can put a neck brace on them and have a stretcher to put them on.

If our trainers are not getting proper medical or first aid training, then they should not be touching injured players, no matter how severe the injury.

Stop the play, the trainer can assess the situation and contact a ground medic to attend and verify if its safe to assist a player from the field and the best manner in which to do so.

Injuries are not that frequent in the game, especially as they happen on field, so these simple practices should be something that is implemented immediately, because all it takes is one bad mistake to make a treatable injury a life changing one.